Sunday Gravy with yeah right: Cast Iron Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza

Hola fellow survivors!

How is everyone holding up?

There was a discussion in the top secret DFO headquarters a week or two ago, where I mentioned that right out of the goddamn blue I had an anxiety attack. No real reason. I guess going to work Monday through Friday in the middle of a MOTHERFUCKING GLOBAL PANDEMIC has some sort of accumulative effect that can randomly rear it’s ugly fucking head.

Isn’t that just kooky?

After several suggestions were tossed around I decided to take these next three days off to drive – by myself – to San Diego County to visit youngest right, littlest right and possibly even our own Low Commander while socially distancing, wearing a mask and chilling the fuck out outside(!) on a secluded beach or pool area.

Consume some local craft beers, soak up some sun, maybe grab a pie from Pizza Port and just fucking relax.

I need a goddamn break.

I plan on being back here next week as scheduled so there’s no danger of missing your Sunday Gravy fix.

So, Cast Iron Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza!

Holy shit that’s a lot of goddamn adjectives.

By the way I have no intention of turning this post into a pointless pizza style flame war.

Fuck that!

I love Chicago style deep dish pizza. My personal favorite is Lou Malnati’s and if you take a look at one of their pies…

image via Lou Malnati’s

You will notice that they use real tomatoes rather than sauce to top their pizza.

I also love New York style pizza. We have a Grimaldis’ location here in my town that makes a stupid delicious pie. Alas I haven’t had a chance to consume said pie since the shutdown. Oh, they’re open for carryout/delivery but there is no question that their pizza needs to be consumed right after it comes out of the oven and the drop-off in awesomeness when it cools off is pretty fucking severe.

What I mean is enjoy any and all types of pizza. Our world is too goddamn divisive already and we need to stop the ridiculous food wars.

/end rant.

Let’s go ahead and try this baby out.

Please note: this is my first time using my cast iron skillet to make deep dish pizza. In truth I was inspired by our own Beer Guy Rob who shared his success with making one of these on one of his open threads. I didn’t have much luck tracking the evidence down though. I scrolled through most of the summer and into May and it simply caused too much pain reliving these past few months.

Sorry Beer Guy. Feel free to post a photo in the comment section.

As most of you know the Chicago style pie is built upside down. Meaning crust, then cheese then toppings fillings then sauce. This is surprising pretty simple to do with the one tricky element being the dough. We’ll get to that in a bit.

First, let’s start with the sauce.

For the sauce we will be using my very own uncooked or raw pizza sauce first featured on episode 1 of our flatbread adventure.

Pizza sauce:

(1) 15 oz can of tomato sauce – or diced tomatoes

(1) 6 oz can of tomato paste

1/2 tablespoon of dried oregano

1/2 tablespoon of dried basil

1 1/2 teaspoons of granulated garlic

1/2 tablespoon of paprika

1/2 tablespoon of crushed red pepper flake (optional)

Gather.

You may notice that I’m using the diced tomatoes instead of tomato sauce to pseudo-simulate the authentic tomato topping like Lou’s pie up there.

Combine.

I made the sauce a couple of hours in advance to let the flavors meld. Cover the sauce with some plastic wrap and refrigerate until ready to cook.

Next we make with the fuckin’ dough over here!

The inspiration for the dough recipe came from Seasonsandsuppers.ca.

And holy fucking hell is it a challenge to read through the names of some of these online food blogs while researching the recipes without gagging. Jesus.

Dough recipe: verbatim from the aforementioned linked website

3/4 cup lukewarm water
1 Tbsp active dry yeast
1/4 cup cornmeal
1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
2 Tbsp. olive oil
1 Tbsp. honey (or white sugar)

It’s key to note that the above recipe is specifically for a 10″ cast iron skillet.

Well guess what? I’m sporting a 12″ uh cast iron skillet.

Therefore I used a full cup of water, 2 packages of yeast, 1/3 cup of the corn meal and it was closer to 2 1/2 cups of flour and 3 tablespoons of olive oil. I kept the sugar to 1 tablespoon.

This was a little tricky adapting the dough recipe on the fly since baking usually requires pretty fucking exact measurements. This is where my frequent baking over the past few months really helped out and I’ll show you why in a bit.

Let’s start by proofing the 2 packets of yeast in the lukewarm water.

Let the yeast bloom for about 5 minutes.

Next we will add the hook attachment to our mixer and add in the cornmeal, sugar, oil and the first cup and 1/4 of the flour to make a “sponge.”

Turn the mixer to a low setting and mix for a couple of minutes.

To build the dough we will gradually add in the flour until we reach the desired consistency. It may need all of the remaining cup and 1/4 of flour, or it may need a little less or it may need a little more.

Let me illustrate.

Learning point here.

See the dough sticking to the bottom of the bowl a bit? This is after 1 full cup of flour had been added to the sponge. This is too damn sticky. Keep adding flour a bit at a time until the dough pulls away from the side while the mixer is kneading it.

Once you’ve reached the right dough consistency form the dough into a ball

Place in a large lubed-up bowl and cover with a clean kitchen towel. Let rise until doubled in size. About an hour should do it.

Now what should we consider as the fillings for this deep dish beast?

How about…

Saucisse!

Any self respecting Chicago style deep dish fan knows that the primary ingredient to that fat ass pie is almost always sausage.

It’s the Chicago way.

I’m using a full pound of “hot” Italian sausage and about half a pound of “sweet” sausage.

Give them links a quick circumcision and remove the sausage from their casings. The bulk sausage is a bit easier to do.

I combined the 2 types and added them to a skillet to brown.

Psst! Hey you! Yeah you. Every recipe I read said to fully brown the sausage during this step.

Know what I say to that?

FUCK OFF!

This motherfucker is going into a 425 degree oven for 40 minutes to cook. That sausage would be dryer than a prairie dogs butthole if we fully browned it at this stage.

Get it brown but not fully cooked.

Remove the mostly cooked sausage to a bowl and cover with foil and make sure nobody stops by for a quick sneak bite. That could be like, bad and shit.

We’re using our bad ass 12″ beast for this ‘un. Coat it well with some olive oil.

Think this recipe might be a good test of how well your skillet surface is treated?

Bet your damn ass it is.

Let’s check on the dough.

Well that certainly fluffed right the fuck up, didn’t it. Remove the dough to a floured surface to roll out. If the dough is still slightly sticky at this point tossing it around in the flour that’s now on the rolling surface should suffice.

Now form the dough into what will be our crust. Spread it out over the skillet surface.

You want to push the dough up the sides of the skillet to get the full “deep dish effect.” Maybe 2/3rds of the way up the side. The linked recipe site up there said to make sure the filling of the pizza is right at the top of the dough so the crust doesn’t brown too much.

Sage advice.

To build our monstrosity today you’re going to need some cheese.

That is one pound of fresh whole milk mozzarella right there. Cut it into 1/2″ wedges and cover the entire bottom surface of the pizza.

.

Now you got it!

Next we add in the sausage.

You’re probably looking at that and thinking “Holy shit that’s a lot of fucking sausage!”

And you would be right!

But why stop there? If we are fully commiting ourselves to the full-on deep dish experience you’ve got to basically say “Fuck counting calories, man!”

How about some trusty pepperoni too?

Goddamn right we did. Full layer. Ain’t no skimping on this bastard.

Then the sauce.

Be sure to cover that entire layer of meaty goodness. The sauce acts as a type of insulation to ensure the filling fully cooks and it also keeps the layer of cheese nice and gooey!

We want that yes?

But wait! There’s more!

That is some fresh grated parmigiano reggiano right on top.

Using both hands to lift the skillet, into the pre-heated oven this baby goes. Maybe calling this a “baby” isn’t appropriate because that’s gonna be one fat fucking baby if it weighs as much as this thing does.

Cook the pizza for 30 minutes. After the 30 minutes add a loose sheet of aluminum foil over the top and let cook for an additional 10 minutes. The extra time makes sure the filling is fully cooked through and the foil keeps the crust from over-browning.

Let’s take a peek shall we?

OHHHH MAN! Lookit that!

Know what you are going to do now?

Set a goddamn kitchen timer for 10 minutes and leave this damn thing alone. You want to retain the skin on the roof of your mouth dontcha? Plus the pie slices better once it’s had a chance to set-up.

But what does a slice look like?

I mean up close?

I mean up really close?

Can we sprinkle some extra parmesan on there?

Now we’re fuckin’ talking!

Holy Jesus is this thing good! I mean, how can it it NOT be delicious the way we prepared it?

“Sausage forward” would be a good way to describe it. The cheese is perfectly gooey and that sauce on top? Very tomato – centric with the little added kick from the basil, oregano and paprika.

It’s rich – no shit – it’s filling –  I’m stating the obvious aren’t I? It’s caloric?

It’s fucking fantastic. Absolutely as delicious as it looks and really, really close to some of the best Chicago style deep dish pies I’ve had.

And the skillet cleaned up with a simple wipe from a paper towel. ZERO sticking!

No, you can’t eat this every day, no matter how suicidal you may be.

But on a special occasion break this bastard out. This thing can EASILY feed 4 people and it would be a great dish to spring on unsuspecting friends or family. Maybe not if they are vegan but you know what I’m saying over here.

The day after serving this I did do an extra mile on my morning walk but that probably didn’t even scratch the surface.

Times are really fucked up right now and this meal will not only distract you from our current world events, it will feed your soul. Besides, you wouldn’t even have the energy for anything but a nap after eating this.

Welp, I’m heading to the beach tomorrow for some sun and surf and a different fucking vista if nothing else.

See you on the other side.

Be well folks!

PEACE and UNITY!

5 7 votes
Article Rating
yeah right
yeah right is a fully vaccinated lifelong Vikings fan, food guru and LA Harbor resident with a black belt in profanity.
Subscribe
Notify of
102 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
WhyEaglesWhy

I’m reading this first thing in the morning and I want it for breakfast. Well done! I’ve never had one in Chicago, but there is a kickass place called Hollywood Pies in LA. This looks amazing.

Also, you are correct that all pizzas are delicious. Well, except that Connecticut shit with clams on it. That can go fuck itself.

Take care of yourself!

Doktor Zymm

That is truly a thing of beauty! And I concur that all types of pizza are good types of pizza. There are only two things that can ruin pizza for me and that’s a) cheeseless pizza and b) sugary tomato sauce

The dough hook is the only reason I might consider getting a classy stand mixer, but I know myself well enough to realize I would use it two or three times and then never again. Sigh.

Doktor Zymm

Also, very glad you’re able to take a quick road trip and unwind! Have a fantastic time 🙂

trackback

[…] I get going on what I’ve got to say, I must add my two cents to Yeah Right’s immaculate post on deep dish pizza. I too have been working on my pizza game during these dark times. Everything he said I have also […]

Redshirt

…am I’m the only one concerned the website has not only gain sentience but joined the comment section?

Last edited 3 years ago by Redshirt
Viva La Tabula Raza

DFO morphed into Skynet so gradually that I didn’t even notice until it was too late.comment image

Last edited 3 years ago by Viva La Tabula Raza
Redshirt

You have one job during a game when rain is in the area, Grounds Crew! One job!

https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/nationals-tarp-malfunction-causes-game-vs-orioles-to-be-suspended-after-rain-delay/

scotchnaut

Oof. Dallas waited until the last possible minute to put one in the net.

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

comment image

scotchnaut

Look, it’s no secret that Martha Stewart has gained a lot of weight recently but that’s a bit harsh.

Gratliff

Oh hey. They’re remastering the actually good game Curt Schilling’s scam company made back in 2012 with a fucking terrible subtitle.
comment image

BrettFavresColonoscopy

Quick, what’s the Maori word for dead hobo bodies?

https://www.bbc.com/news/amp/world-us-canada-53706732

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

A little extra in every pour.

comment image

SonOfSpam

Spectacular looking pie!

(heh)

Love me some deep dish once in a blue moon. Already a fat fuck; if I lived in Chicago I’d have died approx 30 years ago.

Unsurprised

I think we all would. How Dok made it out alive is a mystery for the ages.

scotchnaut

My own theory is that she was struggling with her weight and had no choice but to move to Cali.

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

comment image

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

comment image

litre_cola

Just shot 6 over in my 3rd round in three years (Thanks Decilitre!). Has a few beers, feeling prettay, prettay good.

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

comment image

SonOfSpam

That/s really good. Did you get through the windmill at the end to get a free game?

Viva La Tabula Raza

comment image

scotchnaut

“Stop thinking, let things happen, and stomp the shit out of that one-armed guy in the stands.”

-Ty Cobb

Rikki-Tikki-Deadly

It’s really, REALLY weird seeing the PGA try to position itself as a champion of racial advancement.

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

“They are as long as there are no tan or darker, or women, or…… okay, those people can do math……”

SonOfSpam

“We have representation from 7 different nationalities and races today. Oh look, there’s Tiger now.”

Dunstan

Without having actually planned it, I noticed today that I have the following:

— several pounds of boneless skinless chicken breasts
— some buttermilk left over from my last batch of pancakes
— a package of “Nashville hot chicken seasoning” from my local spice shop (who I trust to make good stuff)

(Yes, I know, whole chicken parts would be preferable, and I usually get thighs, but the breasts were on sale, and I have a hard time saying no to breasts….)

I’m off to consult my Serious Eats cookbook, but if anyone has any favorite treatments for fried chicken breasts/tenders/fingers/whatever…

scotchnaut

“It rubs the Nashville Hot Chicken Seasoning on its Breasts” is where my slashfic is headed, if that’s any help…

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

comment image

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

Electrolysis and hair curling in the old days was a bit more difficult.

comment image

Dunstan

Wow, Bob Ross really had a dark side.

scotchnaut

I always thought he was kinda shady…

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

comment image

Redshirt

“What kind of bullshit is this?!” – Police Officers and Police Officer Unions, the true source of all evil (non-Republican or NFL division).

Unsurprised

Well, he was a drill instructor back in the day.

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

comment image

scotchnaut

“Walk of Shame?” I’ve never done that, but I have participated in the “Canter of Bad Decision”.

Moose -The End Is Well Nigh

Pretty sure you’ve done the sashay of sexyness.

Dunstan

I’ve been the cause of some walks of shame…

scotchnaut

Tell me about it. You said you had the entire Calvin and Hobbes series but you only had 75% of it. Total turnoff!

Dunstan

Yeah, well, you were only packing about 75% of what you claimed, too

scotchnaut

Whoa, whoa, whoa.You said you’d do me if I had three quarters…

/And I tossed in 2 nickels as well

Dunstan

THEY WERE CANADIAN QUARTERS!!!

scotchnaut

Oh great, here it comes…Dunstan is gonna call me a loonie.

scotchnaut

Just a head’s up for you guys-RuPaul has opted out of this weekend’s NHRA Drag Racing competition.

scotchnaut

“Figures….CHICKEN!”

-Usain Bolt, stretching, wearing his favourite beehive wig

scotchnaut

Crosby and Ovey will always be compared to each other and I’m on Team Alex. He seems so much more genuine a person than Sid. The latter’s ‘people’ seem to have dictated to him what his public image should be and the former doesn’t seem to give a single fuckball. I was certain that Ovey’s breakneck, physical style of play would guarantee that his body would break down in his early thirties but here he is, still going strong. He’s amazing.

Gratliff

Dropping to the 4th seed because you can’t score with an open net and a goalie facing the back of it? Couldn’t be my team.

scotchnaut

Oof. Bruins don’t deserve to win after bungling that goalmouth scramble.

Unsurprised

This rules.

I also understand the bullshit of being a high risk essential worker. It fucking sucks. But at least we have DFO.

BrettFavresColonoscopy

That looks fanfuckingtastic. Well done.

scotchnaut

-My wife, that time I forgot about the steaks on the BBQ and left them on too long

scotchnaut

This might be related-her fave Star Wars character is Chewie.

herodotus450

A scathing hour long takedown of Redshirt and everything he stands for
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4fVOF2PiHnc

scotchnaut

/glass of cider and glass of scotch are right next to each other on side table
//takes massive swig of what I thought was cider

“Whelp, guess this day is gonna go sideways much earlier than usual…”

Beerguyrob

Strange – I see “sideways”, but it’s pronounced “better” in my brain.

Dunstan

“Ok, now you just need a vodka drink and a lager drink…” — Chumbawumba

scotchnaut

George being thorough and good…

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDf0IwXoOmY

scotchnaut

Tried to get the hockey game* to start by arranging some sticks in the form of a pentagram while watching Letterkenny outtakes-all to no avail. What am I doing wrong?

*Leafs game

Last edited 3 years ago by scotchnaut
Sharkbait

Is your playoff beard the appropriate length?

scotchnaut

She’s 5’3″. Is that good enough?

litre_cola

Ok. That was superb.

Gratliff

Patrick Sharp is too pretty to be a hockey analyst. Anyway, here he is giving Jason Spezza that work during the legendary Flyers-Senators brawl in 2004 that racked up 419 PIM, which is a record that will never be broken.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pACJq-f2LIY

Gratliff

And here it is in all its glory. Even has a goalie fight near the beginning featuring Robert Esche. Robert Esche is what you get when you combine the temperament of Tuuka Rask with the goaltending abilities of, well, Robert Esche.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NS-39I9mzqM

scotchnaut

It amazes me that the Sens of that era would be involved in a game like that-with the exception of Chris Neil and Rob Ray they were so frickin’ soft. Super talented, but soft.

Gratliff

The Flyers were still probably goonier than most teams at this point, but even they were half small Euro players by then. Brashear came back to the ice entrance after getting kicked off and was high-fiving everyone as they were getting sent out like a wrestling fan. Fucking crazy visuals.

Gratliff

An interesting point is that one of the players who were still on the ice at the end of the game was Martin Havlat, whose fault this whole thing was. He took a baseball swing at Mark Recchi’s head in their previous game and everyone wanted to murder him. Refs threw his ass in the penalty box immediately to serve the extra instigator penalty and he managed to completely avoid getting killed.

Game Time Decision

Championship PLL game is on NBC right now if anyone needs a sportsball fix early

Game Time Decision

Curious if this would work in a non cast iron pan and just a nonstick one?
And God damn does this look good. Reading and seeing that pizza while eating oatmeal is not conducive to eating well today. Going to see if I can convince my picky family to try this out. They didn’t believe me about your flat bread pizza, which they now love, so hoping I can use that to get them to try this one.
And safe travels my interwebs friend. We all need a break sometimes. Nothing wrong with that. In fact good on you for recognising that you weren’t doing well and taking steps to try to get better

Gratliff

I imagine the levels of dissociation taking place right now has to be off the charts. It’s fucking brutal for medical workers, but to some extent it’s something they knew they could have to deal with when they signed up for it, but for shit like service workers, it has to just break the brain. Already a demoralizing position to be in day-to-day, and now you have to risk dying to do it on top of psychotic, equally broken customers.

Gratliff

Where I work, we were all given the option to work from home, and the most troubling thing to me is how many people REFUSED to work from home. People demanding they be allowed to come in to do just that sort of work. Every school was closed. All they could do was paperwork. I was tasked with providing access and resources to everyone so they could do everything without coming in and could not believe how many people didn’t want it.

Unsurprised

I love my job. We could do it from home but the department heads are fucking idiots so our most essential and trained employees have been on leave since March. The pay is fine, I guess. But it’s bullshit when your employer is basically as much an asshole as the MAGA people but don’t even have the decency to admit they are being assholes. But I sit in front of a computer all day and basically determine the fate of people’s lives, so what do I have to complain about?

Mr. Ayo

Skillet pizza is the best pizza. I usually do pan style, but will have to try this.

Sharkbait

Also, what is your method to re-season cast Iron? I did mine a little while ago and it already looks like it needs it again.

Dunstan

I recently made a gumbo, and decided to try cooking the roux in the oven in my cast iron, to save myself all the stirring. Not only is it a great method for roux, it has the fringe benefit of re-seasoning your pan.

Dunstan

Of course, reading this thread reminded me that I might as well pour the bacon grease from the roasting pan I used this morning into the cast iron (which was already dirty from hash browns and eggs) and let it sit for a bit.

Yes, I had a “healthy” breakfast today…. but I was a good boy and put the rest of the uncooked bacon in the freezer to postpone the next assault on my arteries.

Porky Prime

I found my wife’s old cast irons in the garage. They were crusty and dusty as shit. I used this little chainmail bit that came with an even bigger pan I got as a gift to scrub out the rust and what was probably old food particles. Now I love cleaning these things out when something gets a little stuck. Even boiling out egg bits and re-seasoning the pan with veg oil or bacon and firing up the oven is oddly satisfying.

Sharkbait

Mrs. Sharkbait and I had friends that lived in Chicago that we would visit a couple times a year, and every time we went we would go to Lou Malnati’s. So fucking good. Too bad those friends moved. Though I’d go to Chicago for more Lous anytime.

New Haven still has the best pizza though. Pepe’s for life.

blaxabbath

My one brief visit to Chicago was consumed with their hot dogs but I went to Minneapolis a couple years back and we went to a neighborhood pizza joint that did the Chicago style. It was awesome. Took forever and Like a slice was the meal.

Combined with the weather situation, I am starting to get why the Midwest is so damn fat (and I’m talking fat in a nation of fatties).

blaxabbath

I ain’t seen yeast bloom that quick since Donald Trump wrapped up with that 9 year old slave.

Senor Weaselo

Fun fact: When in New York, don’t actually go to Grimaldi’s. Go to Juliana’s (next door) which the Grimaldi family bought after selling the Grimaldi’s name. For one, you can actually get a pie and not wait one eternity. For two, the Grimaldi’s near me closed for… we think IRS reasons?

blaxabbath

comment image

rockingdog

chaser funny:

*Hillary Clinton Voice* I too have a WAP: a Wish to Access the Polls!

rockingdog

found a funny:

i envy cats only having three types of food, called “dry food,” “wet food” and “treats.” its a great system

rockingdog

cool skillet action

herodotus450

Wichita Style Pizza has the sauce first, then crust, then toppings, then is simmered in Allagash White for several hours.

Dunstan

I’m somewhat indifferent to it.

montythisseemsstrangetome

God that looks amazing. I had forgotten how much I miss Chicago style pizza.

litre_cola

It really is the major hole in my kitchen. Any recommendations of what brand to purchase?

litre_cola

Hopefully the ship up here. My usual loophole of my folks being in Retirementville, AZ is not happening this winter.